Yes, fault definitely matters after a car accident. In Australia, determining who caused the crash often influences how repairs are paid for, whether you can access a replacement vehicle, and which insurer ultimately covers the costs.
If you are responsible for the accident, you will generally need to rely on your own insurance policy to cover damage to your vehicle and potentially the other driver’s vehicle. If you are not at fault, however, the situation can be very different. In most cases, the at-fault driver (or their insurer) is responsible for covering the financial losses resulting from the accident.
This includes vehicle repairs, towing, and in many situations the cost of a replacement vehicle while your car is off the road. Because of this, establishing who caused the accident becomes an important part of the post-crash process.
For drivers who were not responsible for the accident, there are often additional options available that many people do not realise exist. Companies such as I’m In The Right assist not-at-fault drivers by helping manage the accident process, assisting with the claims process, and arranging a replacement vehicle while their car is being repaired.
What “Fault” Means After a Crash in Australia
In simple terms, “fault” refers to the driver whose actions caused or contributed to the accident. This may involve failing to give way, running a red light, rear-ending another vehicle, or driving without proper attention to road conditions.
Fault can be determined by the drivers themselves at the roadside. Or it may be assessed later based on evidence such as:
- Statements from drivers and witnesses
- Photos, security video or dash-cam footage
- Damage patterns on the vehicles
- Police reports (if police attended)
- Traffic rules and road layout
Insurance companies typically review this information when deciding liability. In many cases the outcome is straightforward. For example, drivers who rear-end another vehicle are commonly considered responsible because they are expected to maintain a safe stopping distance.
However, fault is not always immediately clear. Some accidents involve disputed accounts, multiple vehicles, or circumstances where more than one driver may share responsibility.
The First Steps to Take After a Not-at-Fault Accident
If you believe another driver caused the accident, the steps you take immediately afterwards can help protect your rights and make the claims process smoother.
After ensuring everyone is safe and moving vehicles out of danger where possible, you should try to collect key information, including:
- The other driver’s full name and contact details
- Their vehicle registration number
- The make and model of their vehicle
- Their insurer (if known)
- Photos of the accident scene and damage
At this point many drivers assume their only option is to contact their own insurer. While that can be one pathway, drivers who were not at fault may have alternative options that provide a faster solution and additional flexibility, allowing them to l get back on the road quickly.
Getting Back on the Road After a Not-At-Fault Accident
When you realise the accident was not your fault, one of the biggest concerns is how you will manage without your vehicle while it is being repaired or assessed. This is the stage where many eligible drivers choose to contact I’m In The Right for support.
For drivers who were not responsible for the accident and where the at-fault driver can be identified, I’m In The Right can arrange an accident replacement vehicle so you can stay mobile while your own car is off the road. Under Australian law, drivers who are not responsible for an accident may be entitled to recover the reasonable cost of a replacement vehicle from the at-fault party’s insurer while their own vehicle is being repaired or assessed.
Like-for-Like Replacement Vehicles for Eligible Drivers
Unlike some traditional hire arrangements, the hire costs are generally recoverable from the at-fault party’s insurer for eligible drivers, meaning there are typically no out-of-pocket rental costs.
Drivers can also receive a like-for-like replacement vehicle, meaning the replacement is matched as closely as possible to the type of car they normally drive. At I’m In The Right, we aim to provide eligible not-at-fault drivers with a similar vehicle wherever possible — from compact cars to SUVs, luxury vehicles, and commercial vehicles, we’ll have a vehicle that is comparable to your regular drive. Once an application is approved, a replacement vehicle can often be dispatched very quickly — sometimes within as little as 15 minutes — so you are not left waiting days for transport.
Can You Go Through Your Insurer to Get a Replacement Car?
Drivers who are not at fault in an accident may still need a vehicle while their own car is being repaired. One option is to arrange a hire car through their own insurer if their policy includes that benefit.
However, the replacement vehicles available through insurers may sometimes be limited. In many policies, hire cars are only provided for a short period (for example, around two weeks), and the type of vehicle offered may not match the car the driver normally uses. For instance, if the damaged vehicle is a luxury car or a larger vehicle, the hire car provided by the insurer might simply be a basic sedan rather than a like-for-like replacement.
Because of these limitations, many not-at-fault drivers choose to contact I’m In The Right for assistance with arranging a replacement vehicle.
What Happens if Fault Is Disputed or Not Yet Confirmed?
In some accidents, fault is not immediately agreed upon. This can happen when drivers provide different accounts of what occurred, when multiple vehicles are involved, or when there is limited evidence available at the scene.
It is also common for drivers to avoid admitting responsibility at the scene of an accident. In many cases, insurers even advise drivers not to discuss fault at the roadside because the full circumstances may not yet be clear. As a result, fault is usually determined later based on the available evidence.
During this period, claims processing, repair approvals and replacement vehicle arrangements may be delayed until insurers confirm who is responsible. Insurers will review the available evidence to confirm who is legally responsible before covering certain costs.
In many situations, drivers who clearly appear to be not at fault may still be able to access assistance while the investigation is ongoing, provided the details of the at-fault driver are known.
Can Both Drivers Be Partly at Fault?
Yes. Some accidents involve shared responsibility, which is commonly referred to as contributory negligence.
This occurs when both drivers contributed to the circumstances that led to the accident. For example, one driver may have failed to give way while the other driver may have been speeding or not paying full attention.
When insurers determine that both parties contributed to the accident, liability may be divided between them. This can affect how costs are recovered and how claims are processed.
Shared fault does not always mean both drivers are equally responsible. In some cases one driver may be considered mostly responsible while the other contributed to a smaller degree.
Because these situations can become complex, insurers often rely on evidence, accident reconstruction, and traffic rules to determine how responsibility should be allocated.
Does Fault Matter for Insurance Claims if You Have Comprehensive, Third Party or No Insurance?
Yes, the type of insurance you hold can influence how fault affects your claim.
Comprehensive insurance generally covers damage to your own vehicle and the other party’s vehicle, regardless of who caused the accident. However, if you were responsible for the crash, you will usually need to pay the policy excess before repairs proceed.
If you were not at fault and the other driver is identified, many insurers will waive the excess and recover the costs from the at-fault driver’s insurer.
Third party property insurance usually only covers damage you cause to another person’s vehicle or property. It does not typically cover repairs to your own car, even if the accident was not your fault. In these situations, drivers may need to recover their losses directly from the at-fault driver or their insurer.
Drivers without insurance may still have the right to recover repair costs and other reasonable losses from the at-fault party. However, the process can be more complicated and may require dealing directly with insurers or pursuing recovery through other channels. This is also one of the situations in which I’m In The Right may be able to assist eligible not-at-fault drivers.
What Evidence Helps Prove Who Caused the Accident?
The strength of the evidence available after an accident can play a major role in determining who is considered responsible.
Useful evidence may include:
Photos of the accident scene
Images showing the positions of vehicles, damage, skid marks, traffic lights, signage, and road layout can help insurers reconstruct what happened.
Dash-cam footage
Video recordings can provide a clear account of how the incident occurred and can quickly resolve disputes about fault.
Witness statements
Independent witnesses who saw the accident can provide valuable third-party accounts of what occurred.
Driver details and statements
The information exchanged between drivers at the scene often forms the starting point of an insurer’s investigation.
Police reports
If police attend the accident, their observations and reports may help clarify the circumstances surrounding the crash.
Collecting this information at the scene, when it is safe to do so, can make it much easier for insurers to assess liability and move the claim forward.
Common Accident Scenarios Where Fault Is Usually Clear
While every accident must be assessed based on its specific circumstances, there are several common crash scenarios where fault is typically straightforward under Australian road rules.
Rear-end collisions
Drivers are expected to maintain a safe following distance. When a vehicle collides with the rear of another vehicle, the driver behind is usually considered responsible.
Failing to give way
Accidents that occur at intersections, roundabouts or when merging lanes often involve one driver failing to give way according to traffic rules.
Running red lights or stop signs
If a driver enters an intersection against a red light or fails to stop at a stop sign and causes a collision, they will generally be considered at fault.
Unsafe lane changes
Drivers who change lanes without ensuring it is safe to do so may be responsible if the manoeuvre leads to a collision.
Reversing accidents
Drivers reversing out of parking spaces or driveways have a duty to ensure the path is clear, meaning they are often considered responsible if a collision occurs while reversing.
Although these situations commonly lead to clear fault determinations, insurers still assess the available evidence before making a final decision.
Does a Police Report Decide Who Is at Fault?
Police reports can provide useful documentation about an accident, but they do not always determine fault in a legal or insurance sense.
Police may attend a crash if there are injuries, major traffic disruptions, or suspected offences such as drink driving. When officers attend, they may record details of the incident and in some cases issue infringement notices if a traffic offence occurred.
However, police reports do not automatically determine liability. Insurers still assess the circumstances of the crash before deciding who is responsible. While a police report can support this process, insurers will also review other evidence such as photos, driver statements and witness accounts.
For many minor accidents where police do not attend, insurers still determine fault using the information provided by the drivers involved.
While determining fault can take time, drivers often still need to make practical decisions about repairs, transport and insurance claims in the days following the accident. Once it becomes clear that another driver caused the crash, many people begin looking at their options for getting back on the road while their vehicle is being repaired.
When to Speak With I’m In The Right After an Accident
Drivers often begin exploring their options once they realise the accident was not their fault and their vehicle cannot be driven or requires repairs.
This is typically the point where arranging a replacement vehicle becomes a priority, especially for people who rely on their car for commuting, family responsibilities or work.
Eligible drivers can contact I’m In The Right to discuss accident replacement vehicle options after a not-at-fault accident. The team can explain eligibility requirements and help arrange a suitable replacement vehicle so drivers can remain mobile while their own car is off the road. For assistance, clients can call the team 24 hours a day, 7 days a week to discuss their situation and next steps.
Skip to content 