How long an accident stays on your record depends on whether you were at fault and whether you are referring to your driving record or your insurance record.
In most cases, people are referring to at-fault accidents on their insurance record, which typically remain relevant for around 3 to 5 years, with the greatest impact early on.
In this article, we’ll break down the answer for insurance and driving records in at-fault and not-at-fault accidents—but first, we should understand what “record” actually means.
Insurance Record vs Driving Record: What’s the Difference?
A lot of confusion comes from mixing up two completely different records.
A) Insurance Record
This is what insurers use to assess your risk.
It includes:
- Past claims
- Accident history (at-fault and not-at-fault)
- Claim amounts and frequency
This is the most important record when it comes to premiums.
B) Driving Record (Licence History)
This is maintained by your state authority (e.g. in NSW, formerly Roads and Maritime Services (RMS), now Transport for NSW via Service NSW).
It typically includes:
- Demerit points
- Traffic offences
- Licence suspensions
These records (such as offences and demerit points) generally remain for 3 years.
Accidents only appear here if they involve an offence (such as speeding, negligent, or dangerous driving). The accident itself is not listed — only the offence.
The key takeaway:
Even if something no longer appears on your driving record, it may still exist on your insurance record — and that’s what insurers care about most.
How Long Do At-Fault Accidents Stay on Your Insurance Record in Australia?
If you’ve been involved in an accident where you were considered at fault, it’s natural to wonder how long it will follow you — particularly when it comes to insurance.
In Australia, there isn’t a single universal rule, but there is a consistent industry pattern.
Most at-fault accidents stay on your insurance record for around 3 to 5 years.
During this period, insurers will usually factor the accident into decisions about:
- Your premium (which may increase)
- Your eligibility for certain policies
- Whether you qualify for no-claim bonuses or discounts
The impact is usually strongest in the first 1–2 years, then gradually reduces over time if you maintain a clean driving history.
It’s also important to understand that an accident doesn’t necessarily “disappear” overnight — it simply becomes less relevant to insurers after that 3–5 year window.
How Long Do Not-at-Fault Accidents Stay on Your Insurance Record?
Not-at-fault accidents are treated very differently — and a common question drivers ask is: do no fault claims affect insurance?
Even though the accident may still be recorded, it generally has little to no long-term impact on your insurance premiums, especially when fault is clearly established.
Most insurers will still ask about accidents within the last 3 to 5 years — regardless of fault — but the key difference is how they use that information.
If you were not at fault:
- You typically won’t be penalised with higher premiums
- Your no-claim bonus is usually protected
- Your overall risk profile is not significantly affected
However, the accident may still appear in your history for record-keeping and underwriting purposes.
This is why you may still be asked about not-at-fault accidents when switching insurers or renewing your policy — even if they don’t negatively impact your pricing.
How the Importance of At-Fault Accidents Changes Over Time for Your Insurance
As mentioned earlier, the impact of an at-fault accident can vary over time. While insurers do not publish exact timelines, many consider recent claims more heavily and typically assess claims history over several years. Based on this, a general pattern may look like the following:
Immediately After the Accident
- Premiums may increase significantly
- No-claim bonuses may be reduced or lost
- You may be placed in a higher risk category
1–2 Years After
- Premiums may still be elevated
- Insurers may continue to factor in the claim when assessing risk
- Pricing may gradually improve if no further claims are made
3–5 Years After
- The impact of the accident may reduce over time
- Some insurers may place less weight on older claims
- Premiums may move closer to standard levels, depending on your overall profile
Important Points Regarding Not-at-Fault Accident Records
As discussed above, not-at-fault accidents generally do not have a direct impact on your insurance premium. However, there are some important points to keep in mind:
- Some insurers may still consider frequency of claims (even if not at fault)
- If fault is unclear or disputed, it may temporarily affect your policy
- Administrative records of the accident still exist
That said, Australian drivers who are clearly not at fault are generally protected from financial impact.
More importantly, if you’re not at fault, you’re legally entitled to be put back in the position you were in before the accident — including access to an accident replacement vehicle while your car is off the road.
At this point, many drivers assume they need to go through their insurer — but that’s only one option.
For eligible not-at-fault drivers, I’m In The Right provides an alternative approach by:
- Supplying a like-for-like replacement vehicle (including luxury and commercial vehicles)
- Charging no out-of-pocket hire costs, with costs recovered from the at-fault insurer
- Allowing you to keep the vehicle until repairs are complete or your claim is resolved
- Delivering vehicles quickly, often within 15 minutes of approval
- Managing insurer communication and paperwork on your behalf
This can be particularly helpful given that some insurers may limit hire car access to a short period and may not always provide a like-for-like replacement vehicle — meaning you could be given a car that doesn’t match what you were driving. In contrast, accident management services like I’m In The Right help you access a suitable replacement vehicle and support you for the full duration your car is genuinely off the road.
For drivers dealing with the stress of a not-at-fault accident, having a clear, practical option at this stage can make a significant difference in how smoothly the recovery process unfolds.
What Factors Influence How Long an Accident Stays Relevant
While the general timeframe is around 3 to 5 years, not all accidents are treated the same. Several factors can influence how long an accident continues to affect your insurance profile.
Key factors include:
- Severity of the accident (minor damage vs major collision)
- Whether injuries were involved
- Total claim cost
- Your driving history before the accident
- Your age and driving experience
- Number of previous claims within a short period
For example, a single minor at-fault accident may have a relatively short-lived impact, whereas multiple claims or a serious incident can extend how long insurers view you as higher risk.
Why Different Insurers Use Different Timeframes
There is no single nationwide rule in Australia that dictates how long accidents must stay on your insurance record. This also explains why insurers ask about your accident history — often going back several years. Recent claims and driving behaviour are some of the strongest indicators insurers use to assess future risk, which is why questions like “Have you had any accidents in the last 5 years?” are standard across the industry.
This is because:
- Insurance is managed by private companies, not a central authority
- Each insurer has its own underwriting guidelines
- Risk assessment models differ between providers
While most insurers align around the 3–5 year window, some may:
- Ask about a longer history (e.g. 5 years)
- Place more or less weight on past claims
- Offer more lenient pricing for drivers with older incidents
This is why comparing insurers can sometimes lead to very different quotes — even with the same accident history.
What Happens If You Have Multiple Accidents on Record
Having more than one accident within a short period can significantly change how insurers view you.
If you have multiple at-fault accidents within 3–5 years, you may be classified as a higher-risk driver.
This can result in:
- Substantially higher premiums
- Reduced access to comprehensive policies
- Higher excess amounts
- Fewer insurer options
In some cases, insurers may even decline to offer cover altogether.
On the other hand, if additional incidents are not at fault, the impact is usually much less severe — though insurers may still look at the overall pattern of claims.
Can You Remove an Accident From Your Record Sooner?
In most cases, you cannot remove a legitimate accident from your insurance record before it naturally ages out.
However, there are a few exceptions or mitigations:
- Incorrect fault decisions can sometimes be challenged
- Administrative errors can be corrected if identified
- Some insurers offer accident forgiveness for first-time incidents
It’s also worth noting that unreported accidents (where no claim is made and no report exists) generally won’t appear in insurance records — but this can complicate future claims if issues arise later.
The key takeaway is that while you can’t erase history instantly, you can influence how it affects you moving forward.
How to Reduce the Impact of an Accident on Your Insurance
Even though an accident may stay on your record for several years, there are practical steps you can take to minimise its impact.
Maintain a clean driving record
Avoid further claims or traffic offences — this is the most important factor in reducing premiums over time.
Compare insurers regularly
Different insurers assess risk differently, so shopping around can help you find better pricing.
Consider adjusting your excess
Choosing a higher excess can reduce your premium (if it suits your financial situation).
Build a no-claim history again
Over time, safe driving helps restore discounts and improves your risk profile.
If you’ve just been involved in a car accident and it wasn’t your fault, the steps you take next can directly affect how smooth — or stressful — the process becomes.
Start with the essentials:
- Make sure everyone is safe and call emergency services if needed
- Exchange details with the other driver (name, licence, registration, insurer)
- Take photos of the scene, damage, and surroundings
- Gather witness details if available
- Avoid admitting fault at the scene
Once you’ve handled the immediate situation, the next step is deciding how to manage the aftermath — and this is where many drivers feel uncertain.
At this point, it’s important to know that if you’re not at fault, you don’t have to navigate everything alone.
Common Misconceptions About Accident Records and Insurance History
There are several widespread misunderstandings about how accident records work in Australia.
“Accidents disappear after 3 years”
Not exactly. While many insurers stop considering them after 3–5 years, records don’t instantly vanish — they simply become less relevant.
“Not-at-fault accidents don’t matter at all”
They usually don’t affect your premium, but they may still be recorded and disclosed when applying for insurance.
“Your driving record and insurance record are the same”
They’re completely different systems. Your driving record relates to offences and demerit points, while your insurance record tracks claims and risk.
“You must go through your insurer after every accident”
This is one of the most common myths. If you’re not at fault, you may have alternative options that avoid excess payments and reduce hassle.
Key Takeaways: What Drivers Need to Know About Accident Records
Understanding how long accidents stay on your record helps you make better decisions — both immediately after an accident and in the years that follow.
Key points to remember:
- At-fault accidents typically affect your insurance for 3 to 5 years
- Not-at-fault accidents are usually recorded but don’t significantly impact premiums
- Insurance records and driving records are separate systems
- Insurers may ask about your accident history for up to 5 years or more
- The impact of an accident reduces over time with safe driving
Most importantly, if you’re involved in a not-at-fault accident, how you handle the situation early on can make a major difference.
Choosing the right pathway — whether through your insurer or an accident management provider — can influence your costs, convenience, and overall experience during what is already a stressful time.
Skip to content 